HomeBlogsBlogsThe Origins of Murder Inc. in New York 1920s

The Origins of Murder Inc. in New York 1920s

Over the decades the Origins of Murder Inc. have made people curious about the dark side of New York City’s history? Many people still are. They want to understand how organized crime grew in the 1920s, especially in the origins of Murder Inc.

This gang Murder Inc. was not just any group; they were a well-oiled machine that handled the dirty work for the mob.

The origins of Murder Inc. started as a way for criminals to take out their enemies. It was led by big names such as Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and later Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia. The blog about the origins of Murder Inc. will show you how this group came to be, who ran it, and how they did their grim business.

By reading on, you’ll see why Murder Inc. is a key part of America’s criminal past. Ready to learn something new?

Key Takeaways

The origins Murder Inc. can be traced back to the 1920s as a group formed by criminals like Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and later led by Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia. They did the mob’s dirty work, including murders.
They used local gangsters for hits and worked with other crime families across New York, expanding their power and control.
The group was behind major crimes, such as Dutch Schultz’s murder. Abe “Kid Twist” Reles, an important member, later turned against them and helped the police.
Law enforcement caught up with Murder Inc., leading to trials and arrests in the 1940s. This weakened organized crime in New York City.
Their downfall showed that even powerful crime groups could be defeated, changing how mafia operated henceforth.

The Crazy Origins of Murder Inc. in New York 1920s

Murder, Inc. was the name given to an infamous organized crime group in New York. It was acting as the enforcement arm for the National Crime Syndicate from the late 1920s through the early 1940s. The origins of Murder Inc. trace back to the collaboration between Jewish and Italian-American mobsters in the 1920s, including Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel, and grew to an organized “murder-for-hire” operation headed by Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and later Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia.

Origins and Formation

Murder, Inc. emerged from smaller gangland alliances such as the Bugs and Meyer Mob, led by Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel in the early 1920s, as part of the expansion and “corporatization” of organized crime in New York.
The group formed as an enforcement branch of the National Crime Syndicate, a multi-ethnic criminal umbrella, created through alliances between Italian and Jewish gangs such as those led by Lansky, Siegel, and Charles “Lucky” Luciano.
Key figures in its rise were Louis Buchalter, the Jewish mob boss, and Albert Anastasia, an Italian-American mobster; both used Murder, Inc. to settle Mafia disputes, eliminate informants, and intimidate rivals.

Structure and Activity

Members were largely recruited from working-class Italian and Jewish neighborhoods in Brooklyn and Manhattan, notably Brownsville and the Lower East Side.
The gang operated out of nondescript locations like Mrs. Rose Gold’s candy store in Brooklyn, and eventually was responsible for hundreds—some estimates suggest up to 1,000—contract killings nationwide.
Killers were paid both salaries and per-hit bonuses, and their families received benefits if they were jailed or killed.

Notoriety

The organization lacked an official name—the label “Murder, Inc.” was coined by journalists in the late 1930s after sensational trials exposed the group’s activities.
The group operated in secrecy, often accepting murder contracts from mob bosses across the country, not just in New York.

Legacy

Murder, Inc. was exposed in 1941 by turncoat member Abe “Kid Twist” Reles, leading to the conviction and execution of many key members and its eventual dismantling.
The concept of “Murder, Inc.” endures as the prototype of organized, corporate-style mob enforcement in the American underworld.

The origins of Murder, Inc. can be traced the consolidation and expansion of organized crime in 1920s New York, blending Italian and Jewish criminal enterprises into a systematized murder-for-hire business.

SHOP NOW ZAZZLE - CLICK BELOW

Why did Murder, Inc. recruit mainly Jewish and Italian gangsters?

Murder, Inc. recruited mainly Jewish and Italian gangsters because these groups dominated New York’s organized crime scene at the time, especially in the poor, working-class neighborhoods of Brooklyn and Manhattan. This strategy reflected the deep ties and alliances between Jewish and Italian criminal organizations, especially after leaders like Lucky Luciano (Italian) and Meyer Lansky (Jewish) began collaborating and eliminating those who refused cross-ethnic cooperation.

Ethnic Roots and Neighborhoods

Jewish and Italian immigrants in New York lived in dense, marginalized communities—neighborhoods like Brownsville, Ocean Hill, and the Lower East Side.
These social conditions enabled the growth of ethnically aligned gangs, providing a ready pool of young men familiar with underworld codes and violence.

Cross-Ethnic Criminal Alliances

The 1920s and 1930s saw Italian and Jewish gangs cooperate to form larger criminal syndicates, such as the National Crime Syndicate, which Murder, Inc. enforced.
Jewish mobsters Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel, alongside Italian bosses such as Charles “Lucky” Luciano, helped set a precedent for joint operations after forcibly integrating previously exclusive ethnic outfits.

Practical and Operational Reasons

Murder, Inc. operated in areas densely populated by Jewish and Italian working-class families. Their backgrounds provided built-in trust and local knowledge, vital for clandestine operations.
Members were called upon to eliminate targets within their own ethnicity, but could also cross these boundaries, with leadership drawn from both communities for greater reach and loyalty.

In the origins of Murder Inc. Jewish and Italian gangsters became the backbone of Murder, Inc. This was because their communities’ demographic dominance and established criminal networks made recruitment easy, loyalty strong, and syndicate enforcement efficient.

The Origins of Murder Inc.

An atmospheric 1920s New York City alley with scattered debris.

The origins of Murder Inc. began when key crime leaders came together. They wanted to control New York’s underworld and started by doing dark tasks for money.

Key figures and their roles

Louis “Lepke” Buchalter led Murder Inc., with Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia later taking over. These men made the group a strong arm of the American national crime syndicate in the 1930s.

Their job was to scare, hurt, or kill people when needed. Lepke started this squad in New York City to make more money and keep his killers busy. He was part of six murders and hid another victim’s body.

Abe “Kid Twist” Reles played a big role too. He worked closely with Lepke and Anastasia. Together, they ran operations that carried out many murders across New York. They were smart and brutal bosses of the criminal world in the 1920s and 1930s.

These leaders used local gangsters from Jewish, Irish, and Italian groups for their dirty work. This mix made Murder Inc very powerful in extorting money from businesses and killing for hire.

But their crimes caught up with them, leading to major arrests and trials that showed how dangerous they had become to society.

Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky negotiated power-sharing deals by forging strategic alliances that blended Italian and Jewish criminal enterprises, focusing on practical cooperation rather than ethnic division. Their friendship, which started in their youth on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, was rooted in mutual respect and shared bootlegging operations during Prohibition.

Creation of the Syndicate and Commission

Luciano envisioned a national crime syndicate that pooled resources between Italian, Jewish, and Irish gangs, ending violent rivalries.
Lansky was Luciano’s trusted advisor, mediating deals between factions and helping persuade other mob bosses to accept cross-ethnic cooperation.
In 1931, Luciano—along with Lansky and others—hosted a conference in Chicago, creating the Mafia “Commission” to resolve disputes, allocate territories, and ensure that Jewish mobs had representation in organized crime’s leadership structure.

Methods of Negotiation

Luciano and Lansky used diplomacy, offering profit-sharing and mutual protection to different gangs, and agreed to settle conflicts by vote rather than violence.
Their deals were cemented by Lansky’s reputation as a reliable intermediary: if Lansky said he represented Luciano, all parties trusted him.
Lansky’s financial acumen helped manage shared ventures, notably gambling operations in Cuba, Las Vegas, and investments in legitimate businesses.

Enduring Cooperation

Even after Luciano’s imprisonment and deportation, Lansky remained his liaison, preserving his influence in New York and international crime partnerships.
Their model of consensus decision-making and joint ventures shaped organized crime’s modern structure and helped minimize infighting.

Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky’s power-sharing deals relied on open negotiation, profit-sharing, and the creation of organizational bodies like the Commission to maintain stability and collaboration between Italian and Jewish criminal groups.

The Origins of Murder Inc. and the Initial objectives and operations

The origins of Murder Inc. started with a clear goal in the 1930s. Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia led the group. They wanted to control crime in New York City. The team did dark jobs like threatening and ending lives for money.

Their work helped them hold power over the city’s underworld.

Their ways were simple but scary. Murder Inc. would finish anyone for the right price, making sure their actions left no clues behind. Lepke saw this as a chance to make more money while keeping his fighters busy.

Murder Inc. big break…..Prohibition

Prohibition drove Jewish and Italian gang cooperation by creating massive profits in illegal alcohol, which required these groups to organize and pool their resources to dominate bootlegging, speakeasies, and protection rackets. The intense competition and violence between ethnic gangs ultimately encouraged alliances, with Jewish and Italian mobsters recognizing that unity would bring greater power, profit, and protection from law enforcement and rival gangs.

Economic Opportunity and Joint Ventures

Prohibition made bootlegging the biggest criminal enterprise, and gangs needed to work together to secure supply chains, bribe officials, and eliminate rivals.

Jewish figures like Meyer Lansky and Bugsy Siegel, and Italian bosses like Lucky Luciano, were instrumental in merging their organizations for more efficient criminal operations, establishing control over New York’s lucrative underworld.

This collaboration allowed the formation of the National Crime Syndicate, a coalition blending Jewish, Italian, and other ethnic gangs, with Murder, Inc. as its enforcement arm.

Overcoming Ethnic Barriers

Earlier Italian crime leaders (the “Mustache Petes”) resisted working outside their ethnicity, but figures like Luciano and Lansky forged partnerships by eliminating those opposed and promoting cross-ethnic cooperation.

Jews and Italians often occupied the same neighborhoods and social strata, making trust and cooperation practical and lucrative.

Organizational Innovation

These alliances introduced new organizational techniques—syndicate meetings, shared profits, standardized enforcement—which changed crime from fragmented gangs to “big business” with national reach.

The alliances not only consolidated power and minimized gang wars, but also laid the blueprint for organized crime’s enduring structures in America.

Prohibition forced Jewish and Italian gangs to cooperate closely—turning competition into partnership for survival, dominance, and profit.

Murder, Inc., was not just about fear; it was a business of silence and shadows.

This quote shows how Lepke turned murder into a daily job, leaving many victims in its wake.

Operational Methods

A shady exchange of money and a blood-stained knife in an alleyway.

Murder Inc. used smart and dark ways to handle their business. They hired killers from local groups to do their work quietly and efficiently.

Contract killings and enforcement tactics

Murder Inc. used fear to control people. They were very good at hiding what they did.

Murder Inc. members did jobs for money. This included getting rid of people who caused problems for the mob.
Louis “Lepke” Buchalter led the group in these dark deeds.
Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia took over later, keeping the business going.
They worked closely with other mob families, like those led by Lucky Luciano and Meyer Lansky.
To do their jobs, they picked killers from local gangs in New York City.
These killers used guns and knives to scare or harm people who didn’t follow the mob’s rules.
Abe “Kid Twist” Reles was a key player, helping plan many attacks.
They got their orders through a system called The Commission, which was like a board of crime bosses.
Dutch Schultz, a big name in crime, was one of their targets when he broke this system’s rules.
If someone didn’t pay money they owed to the mob or betrayed them, Murder Inc.’s hitmen would be sent after them.
They tried very hard to leave no clues that could link back to them or their leaders.
After doing a job, they had ways to get rid of evidence so the police couldn’t catch them.
The fall of Murder Inc came when law officers started linking crimes to Buchalter and his team.
Trials and major arrests followed, shining light on how vast their network was.

This deadly crew made sure no one stood in their way, using any means necessary to keep their power in the shadows of New York City’s streets.

Use of local gang members

After exploring the shady world of contract assassinations, it becomes apparent that Murder Inc. had an extensive network. They were not isolated. The organization frequently coordinated with local gang members to execute their schemes.

This tactic allowed them to blend in and expand their influence throughout New York City.

Murder Inc. employed local gangs for various responsibilities such as observing targets and eliminating evidence. Individuals of Jewish, Irish, and Italian origins collaborated under the leadership figures like Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia.

These partnerships made them more potent and challenging to apprehend.

Solidarity is a source of strength – even amongst criminals.

The gang members derived from groups like the Five Points Gang, the Brownsville Boys, and others from the Italian-American Mafia and Jewish mob circles. Their street knowledge was crucial for Murder Inc.’s operations across New York’s boroughs.

Notable Incidents and Figures

A group of men in 1930s New York City alleyway discussing important information.

The origins of Murder Inc. and the story is full of dark deeds and key players, like the hit on Dutch Schultz by his own team. Abe “Kid Twist” Reles, a killer for the group, later turned against them, sharing secrets that shook New York’s underworld to its core.

The murder of Dutch Schultz

Dutch Schultz, a powerful mobster, made many enemies. He planned to kill Thomas E. Dewey, a prosecutor fighting the Mafia. The National Crime Syndicate didn’t like this plan. They thought it would bring too much heat from the law.

So, they decided Schultz had to go.

In 1935, gunmen shot Schultz in a New Jersey tavern. This hit was the work of Murder Inc., led by Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia. Their group did many murders for the Mafia.

Killing Schultz stopped his plan against Dewey but also showed how strong Murder Inc. had become in organized crime.

Role of Abe “Kid Twist” Reles

Abe “Kid Twist” Reles played a big part in Murder Inc. He was known for his brutal work as a hit man. Reles helped the group kill many people. His actions made him feared and respected in the underworld.

I never liked killing, but I was good at it.

Reles also became known as a “canary.” This means he talked to the police about Murder Inc.’s secrets. His talking led to big trials and put many gangsters in jail. Sadly, Reles’s life ended when he fell from a window while under police watch.

Some say it was an accident, others think not.

The Role of the National Crime Syndicate

A group of individuals conversing in a dimly lit alleyway as a crime boss keeps watch.

The National Crime Syndicate was like a big umbrella for crime families. They made sure groups worked together and Murder Inc. played by their rules.

Murder, Inc. was founded as the dedicated enforcement arm of the National Crime Syndicate, functioning from 1929 to 1941 to carry out contract killings, intimidation, and other forms of violence at the Syndicate’s direction.

The National Crime Syndicate was a multi-ethnic confederation of Italian-American, Jewish, and other organized crime groups formed to unify criminal rackets, avoid destructive competition, and manage territory and profits. Murder, Inc. was established to enforce discipline and manage disputes by providing a pool of trusted killers who could be dispatched nationwide whenever a Syndicate member required a murder or enforcement action.

Key points on the relationship and role:

Command Structure

Murder, Inc. reported directly to the Syndicate’s leadership, receiving orders from prominent Jewish and Italian mobsters such as Louis “Lepke” Buchalter, Albert Anastasia, Meyer Lansky, and Bugsy Siegel. Orders could come collectively from Syndicate “board” members, ensuring that violence was coordinated and sanctioned at a high level.

Operation and Services

Murder, Inc.’s killers—primarily young Jewish and Italian gangsters—acted as freelance hitmen, but were kept on a salary retainer, with additional fees paid per murder contract. Their services were available to any Syndicate-affiliated mob boss in the US, and their ability to deploy anonymous killers helped maintain secrecy and limit exposure.

Methods and Actions

Murders were carried out for business motives: eliminating informants, threatening rivals, or settling internal Syndicate disputes. Most victims were other gangsters, particularly those seen as disloyal, informants, or threats to organized crime’s interests. Killers operated from Brooklyn headquarters such as the Midnight Rose Candy Store, waiting for calls specifying contract details.

Prevailing Influence

The creation and operations of Murder, Inc. illustrate the National Crime Syndicate’s move towards organized enforcement and internal regulation, distinguishing it from earlier, less disciplined gangs. Their activities contributed to the consolidation and longevity of US organized crime by deterring betrayal and external interference.

Downfall

The disclosure of Murder, Inc.’s activities by informant Abe “Kid Twist” Reles led to the conviction and execution of many members, and ultimately weakened but did not destroy the Syndicate.

In summary, Murder, Inc. was essential to the National Crime Syndicate’s rise as a coherent organized crime authority, functioning as its enforcement squad and bringing a new level of systematized violence to underworld business operations.

Coordination with other crime families

Murder Inc. worked closely with other mob families to keep their power strong in New York and beyond. Leaders like Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia made deals with the top bosses of the five families, including famous names like Charles “Lucky” Luciano and Frank Costello.

This teamwork allowed them to control more ground and carry out crimes more smoothly.

Crime leaders from different groups would meet to plan their moves together. This way, they made sure not to step on each other’s toes while doing their illegal activities across the city.

For instance, if Murder Inc. got a contract that was within another family’s area, they would talk it over first. This kept peace among the crime groups and helped them all make more money without unnecessary fights.

They shared profits from various rackets too – from labor racketeering to gambling rings run by figures like Meyer Lansky. Sharing these ventures meant bigger wins for everyone involved while spreading out the risk of getting caught by law enforcement led by people like Thomas Dewey.

Influence on Murder Inc.’s activities

The National Crime Syndicate played a big role in what Murder Inc. did. They worked together with other crime families to plan hits and keep power. This partnership made sure Murder Inc.’s hit men, like Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia and Louis “Lepke” Buchalter, had the backup they needed.

The Syndicate’s support meant Murder Inc. could reach anyone who crossed them.

This teamwork led to many murders across New York City and beyond. With leaders from both the Italian-American and Jewish gangster groups, including notable mobsters like Joe “the Boss” Masseria and Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel, they ran a tight ship.

Their influence was wide, touching not just New York but also other parts of America where their services were needed. Next is the downfall of this deadly group.

Demise and Trials of Murder Inc.

A lawyer presents final arguments in a somber courtroom during Murder Inc. trials.

The end of Murder Inc. came as law enforcers caught up with them, leading to big arrests. Their trials marked a turning point, showing the strong grip of the law on organized crime groups.

Major arrests and trials

The fall of Murder Inc. began with a series of major arrests and trials. These events marked the end for many key figures in organized crime.

Louis “Lepke” Buchalter was captured in 1939. He was a big boss in Murder Inc. He tried to hide, but the police caught him.
In 1941, Buchalter faced trial for murder. This was a huge deal because he was a top leader.
Abe “Kid Twist” Reles became a witness for the government. His words helped catch many gang members.
Reles fell from a hotel window in 1941 before he could testify more. Some say it was an accident; others think it was murder.
Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia avoided arrest for a long time due to lack of evidence against him.
Murder Inc.’s downfall led to many trials throughout the 1940s.
More than 60 gang members got arrested during this time.
The courts used new laws to fight organized crime better.
These trials showed how deep mob connections went into politics and business.

Each arrest and trial pulled back the curtain on how Murder Inc., under bosses like Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and later Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia, worked with other crime families, showing their reach into illegal activities across New York and beyond.

Impact on organized crime

Murder Inc.’s fall changed the game for mob groups across America. Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia, heads of this fearsome arm, met their end—Buchalter through execution.

This was a loud signal to mafia families everywhere. It showed that even the most powerful could be taken down. Trials that followed linked many criminals to their crimes, disrupting activities in New York mafia circles like Genovese and Lucchese.

This crackdown also served as a wake-up call to other big names in crime, from Irish gangs like The Westies to Italian-American mobsters such as John Gotti of the Gambino crime family.

They saw the need for smarter operations and lower profiles to avoid law enforcement’s grip.

As Murder Inc.’s story ended, it left lessons on power, betrayal, and survival in organized crime’s harsh world. Next up is how all these led to significant changes within criminal organizations themselves.

Post Trials and Downfall – The Havana Conference

The Havana Conference of 1946 shaped Luciano and Lansky’s negotiated agreements by reaffirming Luciano’s leadership, formalizing syndicate-wide business strategies, and establishing cross-family cooperation on gambling and narcotics ventures. The event brought together Mafia and National Crime Syndicate leaders from across the US for policy discussions, business planning, and conflict resolution—all under Luciano and Lansky’s direction.

Reaffirming Leadership and Authority

Luciano, recently released and deported, used the conference to consolidate his status as the de facto “CEO of the Mob”: bosses presented him cash gifts to recognize his continued influence, even while in exile.
Lansky, as the key organizer and Luciano’s ally, arranged both the logistics and the investment opportunities, including the Hotel Nacional casino interests with the tacit backing of Cuban dictator Batista.

Syndicate-wide Ventures

The conference addressed major projects such as casino operations in Cuba, expansion of narcotics trafficking (heroin smuggling routes from Sicily and Cuba to US ports), and management of problematic ventures like Bugsy Siegel’s Flamingo Hotel in Las Vegas.
Delegates voted to support Luciano’s network plan for narcotics, which distributed responsibilities across families and cities, making the operation more efficient and minimizing conflicts.
The decision to eliminate Bugsy Siegel, made at the Havana Conference, reflected the syndicate’s consensus-driven approach to business discipline and problem-solving.

More Unified and Organized Syndicate

The conference enabled Lansky and Luciano to present a unified vision for the future of organized crime, strengthening agreements between Italian and Jewish factions, and integrating regional operations under central planning.
Syndicate leaders agreed to settle disputes collectively, share profits, and ensure continued collaboration despite Luciano’s legal exile.

The Havana Conference thus formalized power-sharing and operational agreements, ensuring that the Luciano-Lansky partnership remained the backbone of the American Mafia and National Crime Syndicate’s organization and strategy for years.

Conclusion

Two men exchange cash in a dimly lit New York City alleyway.

Murder Inc. started as a group of tough guys in the 1920s, led by big bosses like Louis “Lepke” Buchalter and Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia. They did bad things for money, including taking out rivals.

These men used local thugs for their dark deeds and worked with other crime families to grow their power.

They were behind some big crimes, like taking down Dutch Schultz. Abe “Kid Twist” Reles was one such enforcer who became famous – or infamous – for his role. The fall of this crime machine came after several arrests and trials which shook the underworld.

Think about how these actions changed New York’s criminal landscape forever. Can you see the effects today? If history fascinates you, dive deeper into these tales from the past.

FAQs

1. What was the origin of Murder Inc. in New York during the 1920s?

Murder Incorporated, also known as Murder Inc., originated in New York City during the 1920s as a group of paid assassins for organized crime syndicates such as the Italian-American and Jewish mobsters.

2. Who were some notable figures associated with Murder Inc.?

Notable figures included Abe “Kid Twist” Reles, Albert Anastasia, Louis “Lepke” Buchalter, Arthur Flegenheimer (also known as Dutch Schultz), Harry “Happy” Maione, Jacob “Gurrah” Shapiro and Louis Capone.

3. Can you explain more about criminal behavior within this group?

The members displayed unethical behaviors that went against moral life norms by engaging in illegal activities like murder-for-hire services to both Italian-American gangsters and Jewish mobster groups.

4. How did these individuals become involved with Murder Inc.?

Most members grew up in an environment where criminal behavior was normalized – many came from impoverished backgrounds or were part of other gangs like Whyos or Eastman Gang before joining forces under leaders like Lepke Buchalter and Gurrah Shapiro.

5. Were there any significant events involving Murder Inc?

Yes! The Castellammarese War between Salvatore Maranzano and Joe Masseria shaped much of Mafia history while Jimmy Hines’ connection to Tammany Hall showed how politics could be influenced by underworld figures like Arnold Rothstein.

6. Did their influence extend beyond New York?

Absolutely! Benjamin Bugsy Siegel’s involvement led to expansion on the West Coast and his association with Las Vegas’ development is well-known whereas Albert “Mad Hatter” Anastasia’s reign saw nationwide rackets being run by the mob.